BJ In The Morning
Welcome back to BJ In The Morning, your favorite dirty name podcast, where we put our nostalgia to the test. With rewatches, first time watches, we are gonna see what holds up!
These two friends have been through thick and thin together for over two decades. They’ve got a wealth of hilarious stories, a deep understanding of filmmaking, and a history of movies under their belts. If you’re looking for some good laughs and engaging conversations about movies of the last 30 years, BJ In The Morning is the place to be.
BJ In The Morning
Primal Fear (1996) - Nostalgia Check
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Welcome back to Nostalgia Check. This week we are watching Primal Fear (1996) for the very first time. Starring Richard Gere, Edward Norton, Laura Linney, John Mahoney, Frances McDormand, and Alfre Woodard, this courtroom thriller has built a reputation as one of the greatest legal dramas and psychological thrillers of the 1990s.
Did Primal Fear deserve all the praise? Does Edward Norton’s legendary debut performance still live up to the hype? And is the shocking ending still one of the best twists in movie history?
In this episode we break down the biggest moments of the film, discuss the performances, explore the courtroom drama, analyze the mystery behind Aaron Stampler, and share our honest first impressions without nostalgia getting in the way.
We discuss:
- Full Primal Fear plot breakdown
- Edward Norton’s incredible debut performance
- Richard Gere as defense attorney Martin Vail
- The courtroom scenes and legal drama
- The film’s unforgettable ending and twist
- Characters, themes, directing, and writing
- Does Primal Fear still hold up today?
- Our final ratings and whether it earns our recommendation
If you enjoy movie reviews, first time watches, classic film discussions, courtroom thrillers, psychological thrillers, and deep movie conversations, make sure to subscribe for new episodes every week. We revisit movies from every year of the last three decades to find out whether they still deserve their reputation.
What did you think of Primal Fear? Did you see the ending coming? Let us know your thoughts in the comments.
#PrimalFear #EdwardNorton #RichardGere #MovieReview #FirstTimeWatching #CourtroomDrama #PsychologicalThriller #1996Movies #FilmReview #MoviePodcast #NostalgiaCheck #ClassicMovies
Be sure to leave a rating, it really helps the show, send your favorite episodes to your friends, family or dog, and check us out on all the social media platforms!
This week's episode of BJ in the morning, we're watching one of Ed Norton's crazy personality-driven movies. Guess which one. Welcome back to BJ in the morning, your favorite dirty name podcast, where we put our nostalgia to the test with first-time watches, rewatches, and everything else. My name's Brendan. And I'm Juan. And we are finishing up 1996. 96, baby! With a crazy courtroom drama thriller movie. Yeah. Called Primal Fear. Primal Fear. What does the title have to do with anything in the movie?
SPEAKER_01Nothing. Absolutely nothing.
SPEAKER_00That's it.
SPEAKER_01Alright, thanks for watching it. I love it. Uh I think this movie, I have a lot of thoughts on this movie.
SPEAKER_00That's why we have a podcast about it.
SPEAKER_01Right, right, right, right. But normally it's like, oh, I love this movie. Or oh, I hated this movie. I'm like. You're somewhere in there? I'm somewhere in there. Which we'll find out as we're done. And that's why I don't want to say too much because I have a lot of thoughts that it's not necessary for me to get into at this moment. I get it.
SPEAKER_00I get it. Um, this movie was very 90s.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Very much 90s. When we watched the trailer, we the first thing we said was a 90s ass trailer. That's a very 90-ass trailer right there.
SPEAKER_00Uh the editing in this, the cinematography in this, the acting, it all music. Everything. The music was so bland and boring in this that I didn't I couldn't even tell you.
SPEAKER_01It's literally just background music. It wasn't even it wasn't even like articulated to like set the scene or anything.
SPEAKER_00No, and it it just it was not memorable whatsoever, which I don't know, is that good or bad? I don't know. We'll find out when we talk about things, I guess. The whole movie was an interesting ride. We'll say that. It's crazy going back to some 90s movies that don't feel timeless like other movies we have watched. This one feels very dated. It feels very much in the 90s. I even think when we watched A Few Good Men, it felt a little more timeless than this one did. Yeah. For comparison to another courtroom-esque movie.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I don't think I've ever seen a Richard Gere movie.
SPEAKER_01You were saying that, and I thought that that was pretty crazy until I looked at a lot of movies that he was in. And I've seen maybe like two other movies. Yeah. So you brought up Pretty Woman, Pretty Woman, never seen it. Uh and Chicago.
SPEAKER_00Oh, and Chicago.
SPEAKER_01And Chicago. Never seen any of those. Crazy.
SPEAKER_00I don't know. I've seen a lot of other people from this movie in other things, though.
SPEAKER_01Like Laura Linney. I always confuse her with uh Helen Hunt.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but Laura Linney was in the details. Right. Funny. Funny. Funny. She's great in this. Yeah. Let's give it up. Give it away. For Laura Linny. Honestly, she's killing it in this movie.
SPEAKER_01She she looks great. She was such a BI.
SPEAKER_00But she's so good at it. She's so good at it. I am just like, yeah, you do whatever you want, Laura Linny. Go off, Queen. Yeah, basically. Go off, Queen. Oh, we had uh a lot of other people, but why don't we uh jump into some IMDB facts about this movie since we're already getting into the swing of things? Let's do it. So, Primal Fear from 1996, rated R, and it's a heavy rated R movie. I have a lot I need to say about the swearing of this movie. Uh-huh. I don't know if I want to say it now or should I wait? Just say no. Okay. It's our show. Let's say whatever we want. Say no. I feel like anytime most people cussed in this, it felt like someone was like, just add a fuck right there. Please. Out of fucking goddamn it right there. Because it it none of the It didn't flow. They none of these actors, except for Ed Norton, feels like they can get away with swearing. In this movie, at least.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00They just don't it that doesn't none of them make it seem like they feel it and they mean it when they swear.
SPEAKER_01I mean, maybe it was on purpose because they're all like churchgoers and they don't cuss often.
SPEAKER_00All the lawyers that are talking about sleeping with each other and drinking and doing drugs and stuff.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, they were at church the first the first scene of the movie.
SPEAKER_00Pretty much. I don't I I think it's for show. Uh but yeah, they just all don't seem like they know how to swear properly. It's like when a kid in like I'm gonna throw it back to like our ages. When we're in like sixth, seventh grade, starting to cuss, and you just put cuss words in front of everything because you're like, haha, my parents don't know. I'm swearing at school.
SPEAKER_01Astarn.
SPEAKER_00Maybe I don't know. I don't know about that one. Turt ass. Yeah, something like that.
SPEAKER_01This bitch ass mother uh freaking uh you freaking suck donkey balls.
SPEAKER_00That's actually like a fine one. That's still better than any of the shit they came up with in this movie. Uh it had a two-hour and nine-minute runtime. Yeah, you felt it. There were times, there were times where you definitely feel it. I have a lot I want to say about the pacing in this movie. Which we'll get into when we do the the the breakdown, because there are just some some things in this movie that kind of rub me the wrong way. The uh tagline. Oh, did you have something? No, no, no. Tagline a high profile murder intrigues a publicity hungry lawyer. That's it. Right. I mean, for the first two seconds, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I don't see that. That tagline doesn't fit for me.
SPEAKER_00Uh, it's got a 7.7 out of 10 on IMDb. 47 uh metascore, though. Wow, big difference there. Yeah, big huge difference. Top cast, Richard Gere, Laura Linney, Edward Norton, uh, John Mahoney, Alfred Wood Woodard, Francis McDormant, Terry O'Quinn, Andre, Andre Brower. And uh more from there. Um, directed by Gregory Hobilt. Hoblet? Mm-hmm. Hoblet. Hob I'm not sure. H-O-B-L-I-T Hoblet. Hoblet? The Hoblet? Hoblet. That's it. Uh, some reviews from IMDB. Are you ready for this? There's I mean, this movie's old from the 90s, it's been around. So let's start with uh a quick one from 2004. I just gotten done seeing the movie Fight Club when a relative of mine said, if you like that movie, you'll like Primal Fear. I didn't believe him because I had believed that Fight Club was the best movie on the face of the planet. Well, he just so happened to have a copy of Primal Fear with him. What? In 2004? Here you go. Here's a DVD. I watched it and was amazed. I was speechless. The movie has so many twists. I was convinced that it was one of the best movies I had ever seen. Gear's performance is average. I say this because it seems that in many movies he plays the same cocky character. Linny's monologue in the core room is mesmerizing. It was just great. And Norton, well, this may be one of the best performances ever. The fact that this was made during the starting of his acting career is unbelievable. It was a great film, and Edward Norton does an excellent job. Sure does. Sure does. Let's do one from the year 2000. Okay. Outstanding thriller on par with the usual suspects. Primal Fear is an impressive film about one lawyer's yearning for the spotlight. He gets his wish after an archbishobishop is brutally murdered in Chicago. It appears that choir boy Edward Norton is the killer, but there is more to this case than meets the eye. In the end, Gere is going to learn that what he thinks he wants, fame and fortune, is not at all that great because what he has had to go through to get there. Primal Fear was one of the most interesting films of '96, but was ignored by almost everyone. Hmm.
SPEAKER_02Hmm. Hmm.
SPEAKER_00Hmm. How about a four out of ten? Alright. This one says it has spoilers, and it's from September 2002. Spoilers. This movie's from 96. Spoilers. This movie's from 96. I saw Primal Fear years ago and I remember not liking it, but not remembering why I didn't like it. Now, I'm not supposed to ever watch this movie again. An actor friend was this close to getting the role that made Edward Norton a star, which is why American History X and Fight Club are also banned from this discussion. But Primal Fear was on TV the other night and I wanted to see it without bias. I still don't really like it. Norton, of course, is magnificent, but the movie is plagued with flaws. The murder was unnecessarily graphic. Did we really need to see blood spurting from severed fingers? And the second act was slow, muddled, and when all was said and done, rife with red herrings, nothing bored me more than the talk about fluctuating real estate prices, which ultimately didn't factor to the plot's resolution. And then there was the final revelation, which raised several unanswered questions. If Aaron was faking it the whole time, then how long had he been affecting that stutter? The whole time he was an altar boy? If that's true, then he was planning the murder before he met the archbishop, which means he would have had he would at any time have no reason to murder him. However, if he created that speech pattern after the murder, surely there was there would be plenty of people who knew he was lying. But while I mentioned many other movies, I'm in no way comparing anything to Primal Fear. It's a four out of ten. Okay, okay. Some it's some brutal reviews over there. Uh, but you know where where I really like getting reviews from? Letterbox? It's it's the letterbox. It's always letterbox. Letterbox is so much fun. This one over on Letterboxd has a four out of five. So it's a pretty good score. Some some reviews that I liked from over there. Are you ready?
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Frances McDormand could have diagnosed Edward Norton as the Zodiac killer, and I would have believed her with my my entire soul. I would simply let Laura Lenny smoke wherever she damn well wants. Fuck yeah. I think all other actors should just go home and apologize for not being Edward Norton. Right. They should. Um, movies in which Ed Norton plays a character with two distinct personalities. One, Primal Fear. Two, Fight Club. Three, the Incredible Hulk. Am I missing any? And the last one, Edward Norton just likes to play characters with personality disorders, doesn't he? Mm-hmm. It's safe to say that most people remember Edward Norton from this movie and not much of anything else. Before I watched this movie, the only thing I knew about it was Edward Norton's performance in it.
SPEAKER_01His performance is outstanding, but he has such little screen time in this movie.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but the fact that that's what people are talking about means that he did destroyed those scenes. He did amazing. Yeah, he did.
SPEAKER_01But I wish I I wish we got more.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I wish we got more, not necessarily of just Edward Norton, but of the disorder, of the switch. We saw him switch a total of three times in this movie. And one of those times was just one sentence. Yeah. And then he snapped back. But when he's when he went off on the lawyer when he was being a dick to him and he started beating the crap out of him in the room.
SPEAKER_00Not in the courtroom, but in the interrogation room.
SPEAKER_01In the interrogation room. I was blown away.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, because that's like such a dramatic uh shift.
SPEAKER_01It's such a huge change. And it's like something that made um Split so successful was that the whole movie was opening the window to that personality disorder. And James McAvoy showed his full range in one movie with multiple characters, and it was just like so interesting to watch because that's something that we don't get to see right all the time. And with Edward Norton in this movie, and he does it three times total total, I just wish we we got more.
SPEAKER_00And see, I think I feel the opposite. I think we got enough of it where it wasn't overdone and overplayed. Because I think the the lasting sting, and we we might disagree on how we feel about the ending, because you think he has a disorder, and I don't. I think he was pretending to have it so he could get away with murder. So the fact that he he does put on this front, and the there's things that I I've noticed that back up my interpretation, and a lot of it's in the courtroom when he's yelling at Lori Lenny's character and fidgeting a little bit, and you can kind of see him like go to to break character and then he he steps back a little bit, but I still don't think I don't think having more of that would have hit as hard. I feel like we would have been like, okay.
SPEAKER_01I still think that it didn't hit that hard though. Like I I personally would have liked to see a little bit more from him as Roy in the courtroom rather than him just snapping and then jumping over the counter and grabbing grabbing her.
SPEAKER_00I I can agree with you there because like having more of that debate back and forth would have been fun.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00But we gotta remember that this is a 1996 movie. This is something from 96 where I don't think personality disorders were like huge, like people weren't really understanding them as much. But that brings me to a big problem I had with this movie, which I'll just bring up now, where it feels like an extended episode of a cop drama or a um like law and order, yeah. Where the murder happens at the beginning, it's really gory, it shows you what happened mostly, and then you're just going along to figure out who the the guy who did it is, right?
SPEAKER_01It probably was a law and order fucking episode.
SPEAKER_00Probably, but when you look at the director, a lot of the things he's done are cop dramas and like TV show detective type type shows, right? So it's it makes sense that it feels that way. But in those shows, the stars are not the perpetrators, they're not the the people who committed the crimes, it's the cops, or in this case, the lawyers.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, that that was a format that worked for that time. Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_00And that's why I think this movie did well in the 90s and it it might not have hit as hard. But also I want to say that I made it to this year, 2026, not seeing this movie and not knowing the final twist. I knew that he had multiple personalities, and I thought that was the twist. So when they reveal it kind of in the middle, I'm like, oh, that's a weird place to reveal that twist. But then the very end where the actual twist is that he's been faking the whole time, which is where, again, that's what I thought. That's where it got me.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So do you want to break down the movie and go plot plot details? Let's do it.
SPEAKER_01But before you do that, yeah, before we break down this movie, before we break her down, dude. Break me down. Why don't you go ahead and tell the people where they could find us and uh all that good stuff? I don't want to.
SPEAKER_00Alright. No, I'm just playing.
SPEAKER_01Fuck myself, man.
SPEAKER_00You can head on down to the description of this episode, and you'll find links to our Instagram and our YouTube where you can go over there and interact with us, find out what movies we're doing way ahead of time on Instagram because we post them early as heck. If you're listening right now, there's people on Instagram who already know two episodes from now what we're watching. So where are you? And they can submit their reviews if they'd like. If they'd like. If they'd like. You can also do that with the send us a some fan mail button that's also in the description of the episode. And then if you're listening on Spotify or Apple Podcasts, go ahead, drop us a five-star rating, helps the show out a lot, makes us happy, and it keeps Juan's multiple personalities at bay. Right. You don't want to meet John. Definitely don't. John sucks. I don't even like him. But Juan, hell of a guy. So five-star ratings will keep this guy around. So let's do that. And then thank you so much for liking and subscribing if you're over on YouTube. We appreciate that too.
SPEAKER_01I feel I'm coming.
SPEAKER_00Oh no. We're gonna take a break uh right now. Uh get John out of here. Uh, and then uh we'll come back and break down details of Primal Fear. So let's break down the movie. Yeah, that's the plan. Get through it.
SPEAKER_01Now that we did all the ratings and stuff, do our ratings and reviews. That's how we do it. And then we're gonna spin the wheel today.
SPEAKER_00Dude, wheel spin day is my second favorite day of the month. What's your first? Non-wins wheel spin days. I don't know. I just I was trying to be don't call me out like that. Uh payday.
SPEAKER_01It was funny. Payday? It was funny. Is that my day?
SPEAKER_00I like payday. Make it sound like we only spin the wheel once a month and get paid once a month.
SPEAKER_01Once a month for sure.
SPEAKER_00Um, my favorite day of the month is the day that I don't have to edit the podcast, edit videos for clients, go to work, um, and I can just sit on my butt and play video games. So Primal Fear uh starts out with a high-profile defense attorney named Martin Vale. He takes on the case of Aaron Stampler, a shy altar boy accused of brutally murdering Archbishop Rushman. It starts with some nonsense we don't need. Yeah. We see we see Marty being a little creepy with Janet. His assistant? Not his assistant.
SPEAKER_01Um, the the the the other Laura Lenny's character. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00He does this, let's dance. There's no music. Oh make music.
SPEAKER_03And then he's like in her ear, like Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And I'm like, this guy's a fucking creep. That is like their way of implying that they have fling. They've hooked up a lot, but it came off extremely strong and creepy, and creepy, especially with Janet not reciprocating at all. At all. And I guess like in the 90s, things like that weren't really he's a rich and powerful lawyer, man.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and she's a lawyer too, but she's hot and blonde.
SPEAKER_01Things like that were kind of went over the head of people, and now in 2026, that did not age at all. Well, like I guess maybe back then it was considered flirty, and now it's just creepy.
SPEAKER_00But he also looks like he's 20 years older than her, and he might be. I didn't look at their ages, uh, but he he definitely feels like a like some predator prey kind of situations, and I I wasn't vibing. Yeah, and when he does it later, it's even worse. Yeah, but he's taking on this case of an alter boy who potentially allegedly murdered the archbishop in Chicago.
SPEAKER_01Which when they show the scene where the archbishobishop gets murdered, all you see is him like getting ready or something. They show a ring he's about to put on, he reaches for a ring, and they just show a knife just go straight up into the air and back down, and this man's hand explodes. Yeah. I just thought, did that man's hand just explode from a knife? I don't even have knives. I have uh knives that can't even cut through plastic. Yeah. How sharp does that knife have to be? It's the sharpest knife.
SPEAKER_00It's from Cutco.
SPEAKER_01To cut through this man's and explode with blood afterwards.
SPEAKER_00It was a interesting choice on that part. Very much nineties. I think of like eighties action movies and how gory they are. Uh-huh. You have your horror movies in the nineties.
SPEAKER_01This was just But that's pretty much all we get from that scene. Yeah. And then we see a bunch of stab wounds on him later when he's dead. Yeah. But I was like, if you're gonna To show that in a rated R movie, why not just show the whole murder? Because we we they can't tell you who did it.
SPEAKER_00Right, they didn't have to. Yeah, I think they could have shown the I get that. They showed more in Psycho than they did in this, except the hand. Right. But Aaron, um, Aaron is running from the cops, he's covered in blood, and he's just running down the the railroad tracks, he gets captured, and that's when Marty decides that's my guy. I'm gonna represent that guy for free because he wants publicity.
SPEAKER_01Interesting choice. At first I was like, Did uh is it because he was an altar boy and he recognized him? But no, it's because he wants the attention and the things that he does to manipulate this fucking case is insane. I've never ever seen a movie where a lawyer is chasing down fucking suspects and other people. Breaking in, stealing stuff, yeah, stealing things, when they shake down Alex later on, dude. Manipulating the story so it goes his way. Crazy. Crazy.
SPEAKER_0090s, baby. Super 90s. Aaron insists that he's innocent and he claims he has no memory of the murder, convincing Martin to defend him despite overwhelming evidence. All of the evidence points to him. He was the only one in the room. There's only one set of footsteps in the blood, and it's his shoes. He's covered in blood. He has the ring of the bishop. He has the ring from the hand that exploded. He did it. Yeah, for sure. We know from the beginning. For sure. But he claims that there was someone else in that room, and that he blacked out during the murder. So he doesn't have any memory of the murder. In 2026, knowing these these things, it's like, duh, that guy has multiple personalities, he fucking did it. Or he was in a blind rage, he did it. There's no question, there's no doubt.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. See, what I do like about this movie is that they lean in to how hard a lawyer will twist the story to uh make it right. You know? So like I I truly believe that this happens in the real world. Probably. Where like he has multiple personalities, and now it's like oh well he didn't do it. Roy did it. Yeah. And it's like, well, yeah, but it was still his he died by his hands. Right? And like maybe, maybe, maybe he shouldn't be in jail like this this kid needs help. But he did it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and their whole thing is that they didn't try him for being insane.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I didn't understand why they couldn't switch the pool. It's a law. Yeah. Yeah. Is that a real thing?
SPEAKER_00They started trying him at for murder and not as like trying to prove that he's insane. So they have to claim insanity at the beginning of the trial, so they know that that's what you're trying to prove. You're trying to prove that he's insane, and he did this because he's insane, not because he's a murderer.
SPEAKER_01So they didn't do enough research.
SPEAKER_00Well, they didn't know about Roy.
SPEAKER_01They didn't try hard enough.
SPEAKER_00But also, because I think that Aaron, Edward Norton's character, are we following Aaron, Roy? Aaron and Roy, same guy. I think that he didn't want them to start trying him for insanity because he didn't because he's not insane.
SPEAKER_01Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_00He was trying to get away with murder. That's it. That's the whole thing.
SPEAKER_01And then when he realized that they were losing, he started cracking more.
SPEAKER_00He figured out his story. And the blackout that he's saying is because there's multiple personalities. So he created this whole backstory about how his mom died and his dad was abusive and he ran away from home and joined the church because the guy took him in. But I think there's a lot more to it. But again, it's like, how long was this charade going on of being Aaron if he had been there for over a year already? Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. So who else has he killed? We'll find that out later. Um, so prosecutor Janet Venable, Martin's for former girlfriend, builds a strong case against Aaron while Martin searches for another explanation. Marty has no fucking clue how he's gonna get this guy off. He's he's dead to rights. He they got him. You know, there's no evidence saying that there was anyone else. There's no evidence saying that he didn't do the murder.
SPEAKER_01And they're trying to find anybody to try to pin this on other than Aaron.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's a whole subplot with like some fucking Chicago gangsters and like zoning laws that has no business being in this movie. They try to pin it on them, the murder, but it it seriously, that's all we really need to talk about. That whole subplot. It doesn't fucking matter.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and that's like what I meant by how much he tried to manipulate this trial was that he was going out on his own, trying to find suspects to pin it on, trying to twist the story to go his way. And I I know I already said this, but it's just so crazy that he's going off to after mobsters, he's going after other altar boys, and other lawyers, and it's like, dude, you're kind of doing too much.
SPEAKER_00And they they bring like later on, he brings the lawyer to the stand that he's trying to like pin everything on, and he does this whole spiel and they get all this information out, and then and then the uh Janet, Laura Linny's character, says objection, and then the judge is like, yeah, this doesn't matter, strike it from the record, don't pay attention to that. It did not matter. Yeah, we didn't need any of that shit.
SPEAKER_01We didn't need a lot of this stuff, we're way ahead right now.
SPEAKER_00So let's bang it back up. Okay, bang it up, bang it up. So Martin discovers on this journey of trying to pin the crime on anyone else that he can, that the archbishop was abusing young boys and secretly recording the abuse, revealing a much darker side to the victim. So they find a tape after they chase down uh the two lawyers chase down a random kid who knows the information of the archbishop making his own we can't say the P word. Videos, sexual activity videos, uh uh spicy movies. Let's say that spicy movies making his own spicy movies, which A, he's a man of God. Shouldn't be making those. Right. B he tells the kids I don't want to say that either. The guys? He tells Aaron and Alex and Linda, who was Aaron's girlfriend before, that they're doing it in the name of God. But he's just doing it so he can get off, basically, right? Because he's an archbishop, he's not supposed to be doing that stuff. But that raises an this whole other subplot of nonsense that's going on, but it also gives motive for Aaron to have killed the archbishop. That's a problem. And now they can't find Linda, they don't know where she's at, trying to get more information, so they start probing Aaron about Linda and about the tapes, and we start seeing glimpses of this anger inside of him when Francis McDormand starts doing her psych psychological examination on him and he claims he blacked out and doesn't remember being upset with her at all.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So that's when we start seeing the cracks start start forming, right?
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_00So Dr. Arrington, who's played by Francis McDormand, uh tries to diagnose him with dissociative identity disorder or multiple personalities. The second personality, Roy, emerges. Roy is aggressive, violent, and claims that he killed the archbishop to protect Aaron. And we find this out while he's alone with Martin, just the two of them, the camera's off, just the two of them. He comes out and beats the shit out of Marty until they come to an understanding. And I really liked this. I liked Edward Norton's take on Roy because, like, yeah, he's super violent and everything like that, but he also plays him with this weird kind of like what's the word I'm like almost polite in a way.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Once he gets past the violent nature. Polite might not even be the right word, but cordial. Yeah, kinda. I don't know.
SPEAKER_01He it's a good villain, he's just uh an overprotective fake brother, basically. You know, and he's like, hey, I'm not a bad guy here, but if I have to break your nose, I'm gonna break your fucking nose, you know, and it's just like I know that feeling, and I'm sure a lot of people know that feeling, but not only that though, he does have anger problems, like he is so quick to snap, and that's where you know, like later on when I said it should have been longer, because I enjoyed the conversation that Roy and Marty had after he beat the shit out of him. I enjoyed that back and forth right there. Yeah, and if I would have seen that in the courtroom, or like he's you know, let's say he he comes out as Roy and then like Aaron comes back, and then he's Roy again, and it's like I wanted to see like that struggle between the two personalities.
SPEAKER_00But I think that's the reason I don't think that he actually has multiple personalities, or it was just written badly. I'm I'm I don't know, I didn't write it, uh, but I I do I do not think that he has multiple personalities. I think it's all a f it's all fake, personally. But after this, Martin shifts his entire defense to trying to prove that Aaron was not legally responsible because of his mental condition. But as we said, they can't go back and change why they're trying him because they're trying him for murder and not for being insane. Uh, the jury finds Aaron not guilty by reason of insanity because during the courtroom, Marty provokes Aaron to get angry enough for the Roy personality to come out while Janet is interrogating him. And he loses a shit, and we have a fucking few good men moment where he screams and yells, jumps over, tries to beat up the the the lawyer, Janet. Yeah. It's a whole mess, and everyone's like, oh my god, he's totally insane. And when we get to to the end of the movie Marty goes back to to talk to Roy after everything. Before then, the lawyers go and meet with the judge in the room, and that's we gotta talk about this scene because I fucking hated it. Um so they're talking to the judge and saying like they're gonna just count it as a mistrial and retry him for insanity and plead all that nonsense, right? And Janet is gonna lose her job because of all the things that happen. She's freaking out, she's like shaking violently, trying to light a cigarette, and when the judge leaves, it's just Marty and Janet alone, and he pulls that fuck in the we should dance, there's no music, and he starts humming in her ear and everything while she is crying.
SPEAKER_01And this time it seems like he's trying to comfort her, and she don't want it.
SPEAKER_00No, she don't want none of it. No, and the way that he's trying is just again, it is so creepy, super creepy, it just felt gross, and I was like, I want this guy to lose his job. I hated it. But then he says, I'm gonna go meet up with my my client, and he goes in and meets Aaron in the jail, tells him the good news, and Aaron says something like, Well, I hope you can tell Miss Vannable I'm sorry about her neck, even though five seconds earlier he said, I blacked out, I don't remember anything. And he drops the fucking act real quick and just is full Roy after this and gives this whole monologue about like I thought we were into in on this together, like you're gonna remember this for the rest of your life, that you got me off, you know, for for being a murderer because I'm insane. And I'm like, why didn't you just go, well, I heard the guards talking about it, yeah, and keep the act up, right? We wouldn't get the reveal where there's he says there was never Aaron. He's always been Roy. Yeah, and that's why I think that he was faking everything the whole time. Um, so yeah, he faked, in my opinion, I'll say allegedly. I mean, that it makes sense. But he faked the disorder the entire time and committed the murder knowingly, and that's when Marty realizes he's been completely manipulated. So he did all this manipulating throughout the entire movie, going and fighting off random fucking people that had nothing to do with anything, getting someone killed. He got it, he got one of the mob guys killed for saying he would come and uh testify against the other lawyer that he doesn't like. He got that guy killed and he let a murderer off. Yeah, so he spent all this time getting manipulated while he thought he was manipulating everything else. Right. So he walks through the the the courtroom and just I love the scene that it follows him through the courtroom and the camera turns upside down, like that shot. His whole life just fucking flipped over. He's done. Like he's not gonna be able to trust anything that anyone says anymore. And he's a lawyer, right? And that's where the movie ends. And it's over, and it's over. So I I'm gonna I'm gonna go. I'm gonna go. Go for it. I'm gonna go first this time. I'm not even gonna ask you. Fuck you. I'm just kidding. Go for it. Go for it, go for it. Okay. A lot of this movie I was completely locked in. The subplots with the the zoning permits and the taxing and the the other lawyer guy that he used to work for that he left and whatever, none of that stuff was necessary. I hated when they started like breaking into the victim's home and stealing stuff, chasing the other altar boy. Um, it's revealed that Roy killed Linda at the end, right? So um he he drops the C word when he talks about her. So my my point of view from the from this whole thing was like I was locked in for the parts where they're in the courtroom again, where Edward Norton's doing his his um psychological psychiatric, he's doing his mental health evaluation with Francis McDormand. Uh those scenes, I was completely locked in. Anytime Edward Norton was on, I was locked in. Anytime that the lawyers are doing their lawyer thing and talking to people on the stand and everything like that. I loved the judge. She is so fucking funny. Yeah, she walks in and just is like, sit down, like get over, let's get this over with, always has a drink in her hand. Funny as fuck. Honestly, great. Loved it. The fact that we had so many recognizable people in this in this movie from from other things we've seen, right? Um, Locke from Lost is in this. That's pretty funny. Um, the the chief from Brooklyn 99, yeah, he's he's in this. Um, saying he used to be a cop. So now I'm just saying it's canon that this is what he did. And then he then he became the chief of 9-9, right?
SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um, left Chicago, got out of there. Uh his character's great. Uh, the mom from Liar Liar is in this. Wasn't she? There was a she was an ER? Yeah. Yeah. So you could tell when this movie is made just because of a lot of those people. But again, I was completely locked into any of the drama in the courtroom, but nothing outside of it. I don't care about Martin Vale whatsoever. I think he's a creep. I think he he is a bad lawyer because he manipulates so many people. You can see him trying to manipulate the guy who works for the press that he's always talking to. And he's doing everything at the beginning of this movie for fame and glory and not for anything else. Yeah. He switches halfway through when he believes that Aaron is innocent. Well, when he's innocent, right? Before the insanity stuff comes out, you can start seeing that he's like, God, I'm breaking all my rules, kind of kind of moment, but I don't believe it from Richard Gere. I think he's really stale in this. He doesn't really show that much emotion. I don't know if that's the point of a lawyer or not, but I don't give a fuck what he's saying.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And the amount of times that in the courtroom he's saying something, and the judge or or Janet are like, no, that doesn't matter, and then they both agree and they're like, it doesn't matter. He doesn't know what he's fucking doing. So what was the point of taking the case? It doesn't make sense, except for the fame and glory aspect of it. He thought he was gonna get away with it. Overall, I think the pacing of this movie is abysmal. It slows way, way, way down just to speed up for five seconds or five minutes, whatever, and then slows way down again. All the subplots that we've mentioned, nonsense. Take them out, shave off 35 minutes of this movie, and I think it would have been way better. I don't think I would recast any of the roles just because Edward Norton steals this movie 100%. Laura Linny is freaking great in this movie. Compared to the details, where I thought she was one of the strongest parts of that movie, she is the one of the strongest parts of this movie as well. You know, she can do it all. I don't think I will ever watch this movie again. And I think once you learn the twist about how he faked being insane, there's no point in watching it again unless you want to go back shock value, right? And I do like that I didn't really get that part spoiled for me. I knew he was gonna be crazy, but it it wasn't a hundred percent spoiled for me, which is great. And that movie, this movie's old, you know? Yeah, it's it's 30 years old. Not bad. But I don't think I'll watch this movie ever again. Um, it's a good first time. Like if you're going through the rabbit hole of courtroom drama movies, I think it's a must-watch. If you're wanting to watch all of Edward Norton's films, it's a must-watch. I don't think it's his best. It's one of his first, one of his first. It's what got him Fight Club and American History X. Don't watch American History X. That movie's terrifying.
SPEAKER_02Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_00I don't even want to say it's good because it's so shocking and jarring and graphic, whatever. But it was fun. It was fun for and I kept reminding myself this movie's from the 90s. There's movies from the 90s. Just let it go. Get over the nonsense, get over the dry acting. The cinematography, like I said at the beginning, is bland. It is very static, it's very 90s TV show style. Yeah, there's some good shots here or there, but overall, the lighting's bland. The sets are exactly what you expect from a courtroom drama. But overall, it is I liked this movie a lot. But I have no desire to watch it ever again. I'm giving it a seven. Seven out of ten. Wow. It's really good. I was locked in, I was a hundred percent locked in while watching it, but as I sat on it and thought about it after watching it, I don't ever want to watch it again. But it was fun. I had a good time. Yeah, I wanted to see what happened, I wanted to get to the next part, and when it ended, I was like, damn, that was fun. So seven. It's a high rating for me. Yeah. I feel like I give I give a lot of six, seven, eight, but I'm I'm sticking with my guns. I'm giving it a seven.
SPEAKER_01I think the pacing of this movie was excruciatingly slow. Oh, yeah. W especially the scenes without Edward Norton. Um Richard Gere was not interesting enough for me. Nope. For him to be the main character. And he's creepy as fuck. Yeah, for him to be the main character that we're falling around the whole time. I had to watch this movie twice. Yeah. Back to back. Because you fell asleep. Because I I didn't even necessarily fall asleep. I was just like f in that falling asleep dozing off phase.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Where I'm still hearing every fucking boring ass word that he's speaking. Yeah. But I don't remember any of it because I'm like this. Uh huh, yeah. I'm doing the fucking uh what's the The uh the clockwork orange? No, the the fet there, man.
SPEAKER_00Get there. Come on, this is an audio platform. The toothpicks. Oh, putting the toothpicks on your eyes to keep them up. I think the clockwork orange got there. Because you're tired.
SPEAKER_01Anyways, so I put the toothpicks in my eyes. I'm trying to watch, and I'm just like, I can't do this. And then I finally watched the whole movie. And now I know why I was falling asleep. You know, because I wasn't like fully awake, fully caffeinated because I try to watch it in the morning. And it's just so just bland and slow. And like you said, every a lot of things in this movie were so unnecessary. It actually made the movie confusing in those parts, you know? Until thank God, Edward Norton's character just kind of ties everything back up together.
SPEAKER_00He's the rug from the big Lebowski.
SPEAKER_01He ropes it in. He ropes it in. He ties the movie together. I just wish I saw more, whether he's faking or not. Because like I get it, the twist. It probably is that he is faking. But if he was faking it, I feel like he should have done it more. Yeah, probably struggled more, yeah. You know, he should have uh slipped up at least once. He should have uh, you know, leaned into it uh even more because like you have this one uh situation occur where uh uh Marty completely flips from he's innocent to he's crazy. And I think maybe if we got a little bit more like of the Easter egg droppings just sprinkles throughout the movie, I I think it would have made more sense. Um especially for the twist. Because I'm like, he was continuously he was continuously on it, and if he is faking it, well he tried really hard to fake it, you know? Rather than just one really bad scene, well not bad, but bad bread. Bad for Marty, you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_00So and I want to point out my if if Ed Norton wasn't in this movie at all, this movie would be a five. Maybe less. But Edward Norton does so good, and Lori Lenny does so so good that I did bump originally I had it as a five, but I bumped it up one point for each of them. Because I get what you're saying. Like having more from Edward Norton would have been would have probably pushed this movie even higher. And if they cut out a lot of that nonsense with the with the other mobsters and the other lawyer guys, and even some of the stuff that they do, like the amount of times they break into the house, um, but like getting the videotape and finding out about the Archbishop is necessary to prove why he has this break, um, Aaron break or Roy or whatever. But yeah, man, I'm sorry, I cut you off.
SPEAKER_01Have you seen Adolescence?
SPEAKER_00No. So in that That's uh the show that does like the one take episode each episode is one take, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um in that show You're gonna spoil it for me? No.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Am I I don't care, I'm not gonna watch it.
SPEAKER_01I don't think so. Um in that show, the kid is crazy and he's he's accused of killing somebody. It's similar to this. But they made him the main character without actually being the main character. So like the main character of the show is actually the family, the mom and the dad dealing with all this stuff. But when they show him in the room with his psychologist, there's this scene in there that really uh shows uh his true colors. So it's like the interaction between the psychologist and the kid and it shows that like at some point the psychologist gets scared of this twelve-year-old boy because of how unhinged he is. I wish that that dynamic is what I wanted to see. You know what I mean? Showing how unhinged this man is, and I don't I don't believe that that man's a killer from his interactions. Yeah, he's violent. I don't believe that he's a killer. I don't believe that he is psychotic.
SPEAKER_00Aaron?
SPEAKER_01Aaron. Roy? Roy Erroy? Either one of them, yeah. You know, like I I didn't feel that if we're in this in the room for too long with this guy, then we're gonna die. And like that's a feeling that I felt in the adolescence.
SPEAKER_00I felt that at the last scene in the last scene of the movie.
SPEAKER_01In the last scene, I can see that.
SPEAKER_00And that's when Richard's behind Richard like Marty's, but Marty's in there with the door open and he backs away. And you feel it then.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Like, if Marty said anything wrong, he probably would have gotten strangled right there. And no one, there's no officers around. There's not a single cop nearby. He's way down the fucking hall. See, and I feel like that's too little too late at that point. Again, though, I I'm giving it a lot of grace for being in a movie from the 90s. Sure. So, what's your rating on this?
SPEAKER_01Uh I originally, especially with how boring and sleepy I was, was gonna give it a 4.5. Yeah. I literally just hated it. When I finally watched it all the way through without falling asleep, I give it a I give it a 5 out of 10. Okay, so right in the middle? Right in the middle. All right. I just I Edward Orton should have been the main character, and he had maybe, maybe no more than 10 minutes of screen time in this whole movie.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So But I I want to point out that I'm fine with that, and that's probably why our scores are so different because I think it was the perfect amount for me. Uh, I'm looking over our list though of movies, trying to see what other big discrepancy we have like that. There's not much. We're pretty much tied most of the time when it comes to movies. We're very close. There's not a single one on here that I think we we really differ that like more than two points. Yeah. Most of it's by like 0.5 or you know 75, whatever. But there's nothing on this list that's that outrageously different. So this is a first for us, man. It's kind of a big difference. Well, look at us making first wonka was almost a two-point difference where I gave it a six, seven, five, and you gave it a five. That's like the closest one to this, to this score. So crazy, crazy scores. I do think now we need to answer the question does this hold up today? Is it a nostalgic movie or is it a good movie? Is it something that people love just for the nostalgia of it, just remembering parts of it, thinking it's better than it actually is, or is it actually good? I think you already answered that by saying that it's not a good movie.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, I mean it's but it's okay.
SPEAKER_00Like, is there a do you think people hold on to it nostalgically for Ed Norton?
SPEAKER_01Uh no, because no, because he has other roles that are so much better than this. And I think you know, when I think of Edward Norton, it's sure we've never seen this movie, but I've never ever thought of Primal Fear. Or if I spoken to somebody They're not they're talking Fight Club who has seen Primal Fear, they're not gonna bring up Primal Fear. They're bringing up Fight Club, they're bringing up uh American History X. American History X, they're bringing up the Hulk.
SPEAKER_00They'll even bring up like what is it, the Glass Onion? Yeah, shit like that. But like this movie. When we talk about Ed Norton most of the time, at least in our circles, it's about how he've made the worst mistake by dropping Bruce Banner because he wasn't gonna get paid enough.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and he also wanted full control of his own script, which was not good.
SPEAKER_00Only Tom Holland gets that. Yeah. And I've heard the new Spider-Man's freaking great. Yeah. By the time this episode comes out, we have seen that movie. The new Spider-Man, by the way. Less than 24 hours, baby. For you. I gotta wait. Baby! You know what we don't need to wait for though? Spin in the wheel, man. Yeah, why don't not wait for that? Let's do it immediately, right now. Right now. I have it ready to go, ready to ready to rock. Are you ready?
SPEAKER_01I wanna rock. Let's go, spin it, baby.
SPEAKER_00Hold on. Let me click it. It's spinning. Big money.
SPEAKER_01Let's go.
SPEAKER_00Oh, it's another recent year. It makes the sound. 2018. Yeah, so we're we're going to 2018. This is a this is a fun year. I feel like there's gonna be a lot of movies we have seen in 2018. What the hell were we doing in 2018? Um I was working at my pizza job full time. Was in in like trainings and supervising and stuff. You were working the job you do now. I was cleaning bathrooms. You were cleaning bathrooms, but still at the same place. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I was working nights.
SPEAKER_00Uh were we living together in 2018? Yes. Yes, we were. We were. It was right before I moved. Right before I moved. We were doing OG BJ in the morning. Wow. OG. And if you're a if you're a fan from those years, the OG years, let us know. Hit that, send us a fan mail button, because that would be really cool to to hear if someone had uh joined us from back then. 2017, 2018?
SPEAKER_012018 for sure.
SPEAKER_002018 movies. Are you ready? Let's see what's on the list. By popularity on IMDb. Number one, Avengers Infinity War.
SPEAKER_01Oh shit.
SPEAKER_00Number two, Hereditary. Alright. Number three, Spider-Man into the Spider-Verse. Number four, Black Panther.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we definitely were living together because a lot of these movies we just went and we saw together.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Uh Ready Player One. A Quiet Place. Deadpool 2. Tag. Game Night. First Man. I haven't seen that. Is that Ryan Gosling? He's real hot right now.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00He just got it. He's so hot right now.
SPEAKER_01He's so hot right now.
SPEAKER_00For sure. Venom. Uh-huh. The Meg. Wow. Upgrade. I remember seeing Upgrade in theaters. Yeah. Yeah. Bohemian Rhapsody. That came out in 2018.
SPEAKER_01That's wild. Jeez. Jeez. I don't think it. I don't think I saw it until it came out on video on demand.
SPEAKER_00Video on demand. Bumblebee. I love that movie. I mean, solo a Star Wars story. Gross. Aquaman. It was a lot of superhero Star Wars type stuff, huh? A Star Is Born? Haven't seen that. Geez, man. Uh, Under the Silver Lake. Have you seen that?
SPEAKER_01No.
SPEAKER_00Me neither. Going down this list though, I went back to the top. For a movie we have seen, Infinity War seems like a good pick. But the number two slot seems really fun. So I think we should watch Hereditary.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Have you seen that in a while? Not in a few years, no. Um, I feel like someone pushed me real hard to watch it, someone from our past that we don't talk to anymore. Um, like, this is the best movie ever. You gotta watch this movie. It's the best. It's so great. No, it's not. I'm it's it's so good. You gotta watch this movie. It's the best.
SPEAKER_01It's so friggin'.
SPEAKER_00They don't sound like this. This is so bad. Uh, they sound like a normal person. Um, comedic effect voice activated. You sound like um was it Fallon when he does the the girls in the basement? What what's the catch the catchphrase from that? Uh you know what I'm talking about?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think so, but whatever. It's my stepdad. I can't do the voice.
SPEAKER_00It's my stepdad. Oh. Oh gross. Anyways, I think hereditary would be a really fun pick because I haven't seen it since then.
SPEAKER_02Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_00I remember being very, very impressed with this movie.
SPEAKER_01And A24 movies always has like a crazy twist. Speaking of twists of this movie.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean there's gonna be better ones in an A24 movie. I'm trying to see if another A24 movie came out this year. Next week, we're gonna watch Hereditary. Uh-huh. A24 for August. The A and A24 is August. I like it. We're starting August. I mean, I think we're already in August when this episode comes out. We're finishing August with A24 movies. Uh huh. I should get our timing right. That's alright. We'll check the calendar. Yeah, we'll figure it out. Next week, hereditary. We're starting spooky season early.
SPEAKER_01Hell yeah, baby. Hell yeah. Oh yeah, brother. Oh yeah, brother. Oh yeah.
SPEAKER_00Speaking of Labor Day, uh, if you're not doing anything the fourth, fifth, and sixth of September, we are gonna be at Tucson Comic-Con. What? What's so funny? It was a great segue. It was great. It was great. Yeah, is that Labor Day? Labor Day weekend. Tuesday on Comic Con. For sure. It says it on the thing. It really is. We're gonna be there though. So please come hang out with us, make some memories with us, take some pictures, maybe let us interview you. We're talking about movies that you haven't seen that you're embarrassed to not have seen. Because that's kind of where this whole journey started was us talking about movies we've never seen that as film lovers, we should probably be embarrassed.
SPEAKER_01We should like why haven't we seen some of those?
SPEAKER_00Like Jaws. I've never seen Jaws. Have you? Yeah. I've never seen it. But it's not in our time frame, so it doesn't matter.
SPEAKER_01I've never seen The Departed. The Departed? Yeah, I've never seen The Departed.
SPEAKER_00Dude, when we start season two, we're changing the fucking rules. Okay, man. We're changing the rules. I'm saying it here, saying it now. We're gonna start to go into a movie I've seen that you haven't seen.
SPEAKER_01I'm just bringing up a movie that's uh for me. The departed.
SPEAKER_00I don't even know if the departed is one of those. Like I've never seen The Notebook. Okay, you gotta drop another one that you're embarrassed that you're embarrassed about.
SPEAKER_01I've never seen never have I ever. Uh another Leo DiCaprio movie. I've never seen Inception all the way through.
SPEAKER_00The fuck?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00You haven't seen that? Okay, we're changing the fucking rules, season two. Season two is coming, by the way, in a couple months. So be you freaking prepared. Anyways, back on track. Tu's on Comic Con. Go to it, join us. We're gonna have fun. We might meet Lou Ferrigno.
SPEAKER_01We're already calling him Louis F, is how close we are.
SPEAKER_00We're so close with him. Louis F. Louis F. And if you've made it this far in the episode, please leave us a five-star rating. It really helps out the show. And again, we're gonna make sure that Juan's head stays on when he's taking out outside the window of a car. That's a tease to hereditary.
SPEAKER_01We also have to keep John contained.
SPEAKER_00John needs to be contained. So please leave us five stars. And if you haven't already, scroll on down through the description of the episode. You can find links to our social medias. We're BJ the Morning podcast on all social medias. So it should be pretty easy as long as you put the word podcast at the end. Don't leave it out. Right. And if you do, safe search on.
SPEAKER_01Images blurred.
SPEAKER_00We were 25 when we made the name for the podcast. So were we that old? Yeah, we were uh 24? I don't know. We were 25. Around then. We were young, dumb, and full of drinking beers.
SPEAKER_01Drinking beer, yeah. Full of beer. Full of beers. Full of beer and whiskey.
SPEAKER_00And Jaeger. We were drinking a lot of Jaeger back then. Thank you so much for listening to this week's episode of BJ in the morning. My name's Brendan.
SPEAKER_01And I'm Juan. And Juan, say your line. We'll talk to you next time.